Hit this link to return to the elected Head of State Campaign Index Page |
An elected Head of State for BritainScore card for monarchs |
I will start with William the Conqueror, as the previous Saxon kings were elected, even if on a severely restricted franchise.
William I |
Invaded England on a feeble excuse. Highly repressive. Commissioned Domesday Book to tax us harder. |
William II |
Similarly repressive. Even the barons who had benefitted from the Norman Conquest did not like him. |
Henry I |
Generally liked, even if he 'liked' wenches too much. Left chaos in his wake (as well as many children, guarateeing we now all carry 'royal blood'). |
Stephen |
Too weak to prevent decades of civil war ravaging our green & pleasant. |
Henry II |
Better. Brought order to the chaos. |
Richard I |
Bad but with an unjustified good reputation. Wasted our tax money on wars, largely in France. Hated in Gascony. |
John |
Actually tried to administer the country well, thus getting up the noses of the barons. Magna Charta is a charter of barons' rights. Unlucky in losing Normandy & having a terrible temper. |
Henry III |
'Brought peace with injustice'...but only after civil war. Another weakling. |
Edward I |
Messed up in Gascony. Conquered Wales - was that really necessary? Died invading Scotland. |
Edward II |
Fought & lost to Scots. Promoted his gay friends over qualified straights & was bumped off horribly. |
Edward III |
Fought unnecessary wars in France. Too subject to the influence of mistresses. |
Richard II |
Tyrant. Betrayed the people by ratting on the Peasants Revolt agreement. |
Henry IV |
Usurper. Murdered predecessor (this is a + point). |
Henry V |
More unnecessary foreign wars... |
Henry VI |
Utter weakling. Lost the war in France completely. Caused the War of the Roses by his feebleness. |
Edward IV |
Usurper. Won War of the Roses. Reasonable administrator but married unwisely, causing political problems. |
Edward V |
We will never know how he would have turned out. |
Richard III |
Good administrator. Gave us right to bail. |
Henry VII |
Usurper. Won War of the Roses mark 2. The best administrator among the royals but with a very dodgy claim to the throne. |
Henry VIII |
Wasted his father's legacy but fortuituously saved us from Catholicism. |
Edward VI |
Died a bit too young but founded many schools. |
Mary I |
Bloody Mary. Enough said. |
Elizabeth I |
Good marks for cooling religious passions & steadiness under fire from Spanish etc. |
James I |
OK. Cunning politician. |
Charles I |
Dismissed parliament. Plunged country into civil war trying to establish 'the divine right of kings'. |
Charles II |
Sold out to foreign powers. Secret Catholic. Tried 'the divine right of kings' on again. |
James II |
Untrustworthy & booted out. |
William III & Mary II |
Beneficiaries of the 'Glorious Revolution'. W spent much money on foreign wars against Louis XIV. Probably just as well. Good marks. |
Anne |
Cunning politician. Not as dim as often portrayed. |
George I |
Boor. |
George II |
Gets a brownie point for being the last king to lead the army into battle. |
George III |
Interfered in politics too much. Questionable sanity with hereditary implications. |
George IV |
Cultured, if nothing else. |
William IV |
Betrayed his real wife Dora Jordan. Allowed Queen Adelaide to interfere in politics too much. |
Victoria |
Ok when she relied on Albert's good sense. |
Edward VII |
The last king to do anything for his country in facilitating the Entente Cordiale with the French. Randy. |
George V |
A king of very little brain. Betrayed his cousin Tasr Nicholas II, when he could have rescued him. |
George VI |
A weak man stiffened by a tough wife. |
Elizabeth II |
Incompetent parent. Attempts, often successfully, to put pressure on elected politicians. Subverts courts. |
Only 10 out of 39 with any positive attributes & only 4 might have been elected democratically (John, Richard III, Henry VII & William-and-Mary). Oliver Cromwell was a better Head of State than any of them (with the possible exception of Henry VII) & his leagcy, except for the Republic, was eventually enshrined in the 1689 Bill of Rights.
If you want to know more, you can always e-mail me.
Other pages:- |
Contact: Ken Baldry, 17 Gerrard Road, Islington, London N1 8AY, +44(0)20 7359 6294 or e-mail him
URL: http://www.ourpresident.org.uk/monarchs.html
Last revised 19/12/2003
© 2001-2003 Ken Baldry, print, copy & pass on, please or e-mail your friends about this campaign.